Brooklyn 99 I Want It That Way Scene

Okay, let's talk about pure, unadulterated joy. Let's talk about that scene.

You know the one. The Brooklyn Nine-Nine "I Want It That Way" lineup scene.

The Setup: A Crime and a Chorus

Imagine this: You're Jake Peralta (played by the ridiculously charming Andy Samberg). You need to identify a suspect.

But instead of just showing a photo array, you have a stroke of improvisational genius. A glorious, hilarious stroke.

He gets five suspects to sing a line from the Backstreet Boys classic, "I Want It That Way."

Why It Works: The Harmony of Hilarity

It's not just about the song, although who doesn't love belting out some 90s pop? It's the sheer absurdity of the situation.

Think about it. You're a hardened criminal, maybe you robbed a bank or swiped a priceless painting. And the next thing you know, you're crooning in a police lineup. Talk about unexpected!

The contrast between the serious setting and the goofy singing is comedy gold. It’s like ordering a pizza and finding out it’s covered in gummy bears – delightfully wrong.

Jake's dedication is key. He doesn't just ask them to sing; he directs them like he's conducting an orchestra. "Tell me why!" he commands, practically vibrating with excitement.

It's like watching a kid playing detective, and that's what makes it so endearing.

The Singing Suspects: A Cacophony of Crime

The suspects' reactions are priceless. Some are begrudgingly participating, others are surprisingly into it.

You can almost see them reliving their middle school dances, momentarily forgetting they're in a police lineup. A brief escape into pop perfection.

"It was number five. Number five killed my brother."

And then Jake's epic line. The "Number Five" reveal. It's so unexpected, so silly, that it just explodes with laughter. It’s like a perfectly timed punchline, but set to a boy band tune.

Beyond the Laughs: A Moment of Connection

Even Captain Holt, a man who rarely cracks a smile, is subtly amused. You can see a tiny twitch of his lips, a hint of something resembling joy.

It's a reminder that even the most serious among us can appreciate a little bit of silliness.

The scene’s brilliance lies in its shared experience. Everyone knows, or at least recognizes, that song. It's a universal touchstone.

Brooklyn Nine-Nine consistently delivers clever writing and lovable characters. But the "I Want It That Way" scene? It’s in a league of its own.

It’s a perfect example of how a simple song and a ridiculous situation can create a truly unforgettable moment.

So, next time you're feeling down, just remember those five singing suspects. Remember Jake's infectious enthusiasm and Captain Holt's almost-smile.

And maybe, just maybe, you'll find yourself singing along. Because that's the power of Brooklyn Nine-Nine. It makes you want to sing, even in a police lineup.