Charlotte Summers I Put A Spell On You

Okay, let's talk about something that might make some people clutch their pearls. It's about a certain song, sung by a certain little girl. Yes, I'm talking about Charlotte Summers and her rendition of "I Put A Spell On You."

Buckle up. This is where things might get controversial (or not, who knows?).

The Tiny Sorceress: Charm or Chaos?

First, let's acknowledge the obvious. Charlotte has a powerful voice. I mean, seriously powerful for someone so young.

But… and there's always a "but," isn't there? Does her performance of "I Put A Spell On You" actually… work?

Or is it a little too… theatric? Is it too much, too soon? These are the questions I'm wrestling with.

The Original Spellcasters: A Hard Act to Follow

Let's not forget where this song comes from. Screamin' Jay Hawkins, of course! And then Bette Midler totally slayed it in Hocus Pocus.

These are some seriously big shoes to fill. Talk about pressure!

Both of them brought a raw, almost unhinged energy to the song. It felt dangerous, unpredictable, and like maybe, just maybe, they really *did* put a spell on you.

Charlotte's Take: Broadway Baby?

Charlotte's version is undeniably polished. You can tell she's got some serious training.

Her vibrato is impressive. Her control is remarkable.

But does that technical perfection translate into genuine spellbinding? I'm not entirely convinced.

Maybe it's because I miss the grit. The vulnerability. The feeling that the singer is about to completely lose it.

It's almost *too* good. Almost *too* perfect. Like a carefully crafted potion brewed in a sterile laboratory.

The Unpopular Opinion: It's Good, But Not Spellbinding

Here it is: my possibly controversial opinion. Charlotte Summers is talented. Incredibly talented.

But her "I Put A Spell On You" doesn't quite cast the same magic as the originals.

It feels more like a technically brilliant performance than a genuine, heart-wrenching plea to be loved. It's a really good cover, but is it an *iconic* cover?

Am I being too harsh? Maybe. But I think the song deserves that raw, untamed energy.

So, What's the Verdict?

Ultimately, music is subjective. What one person finds enchanting, another might find…well, just okay.

I appreciate Charlotte Summers' talent. I really do.

But when I want to be truly spellbound, I'll stick with Screamin' Jay or Bette. They just have that extra ingredient – a dash of madness – that makes their versions truly unforgettable.

Now, bring on the hate mail! Just kidding (sort of).

What do *you* think? Am I completely off base? Let me know! I'm always open to having my mind changed… or, perhaps, having a spell cast on me.