Wayfair 5 Year Protection Plan Review

Wayfair's 5-Year Protection Plan faces increasing scrutiny as customers report inconsistent service and claim denials.
The plan, offered by Asurion, promises coverage for accidental damage and malfunctions but is now under fire for allegedly failing to deliver on its promises, leaving consumers with unexpected repair or replacement costs.
What's Happening?
Consumers are flooding online forums and review sites with complaints about their experiences with Wayfair's 5-Year Protection Plan.
Many report initial purchase of the plan alongside furniture or appliances, expecting comprehensive coverage as advertised by Wayfair.
However, when issues arise, customers are often met with claim denials or lengthy, frustrating approval processes handled by Asurion, the third-party administrator of the plan.
The Core Issues
The primary complaint centers around claim denials citing "pre-existing conditions" or damage deemed outside the scope of the coverage.
Customers allege that these conditions were not present at the time of purchase or were caused by normal wear and tear, which they believed was covered.
Others report significant delays in claim processing, with weeks or even months passing before a resolution is reached, leaving them without functional furniture or appliances.
"I bought the protection plan for peace of mind, but it's been nothing but a headache," one frustrated customer wrote online.
Where is This Happening?
These issues are widespread, affecting customers across the United States and Canada, wherever Wayfair operates and offers the protection plan.
Reports are concentrated on consumer review platforms like the Better Business Bureau, Trustpilot, and various online forums dedicated to home improvement and customer service.
When Did This Start?
While isolated complaints have existed for some time, a noticeable increase in negative reviews and reports began in late 2023 and has continued into 2024.
This surge coincides with Wayfair's increased marketing efforts around the protection plan and a general rise in furniture and appliance sales.
Asurion's Response
Asurion, the company administering the plan, has not issued a broad statement addressing the growing concerns.
Individual customer service representatives often cite the terms and conditions of the plan as justification for claim denials, but customers argue these terms are vague and open to interpretation.
Some customers report difficulty reaching Asurion representatives or receiving consistent information across different communication channels.
"The runaround I've gotten from Asurion is unbelievable. They keep passing me back and forth and no one seems to be able to help," shared another affected buyer.
How Are Customers Reacting?
Consumers are increasingly advising others to avoid Wayfair's 5-Year Protection Plan, citing it as a waste of money and a source of unnecessary stress.
Some are pursuing legal action or filing complaints with consumer protection agencies in an attempt to resolve their disputes.
Social media campaigns are also emerging, aiming to raise awareness of the alleged issues and pressure Wayfair and Asurion to improve their service.
What's Next?
The situation is ongoing, with consumer advocates calling for greater transparency and accountability from both Wayfair and Asurion.
Consumers are encouraged to carefully review the terms and conditions of the protection plan before purchasing and to document all communication with Asurion.
Further investigation is needed to determine the extent of the problem and whether regulatory action is warranted to protect consumers from potentially deceptive practices.

















